Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
granville1
ParticipantCongratulations, Justy – another grand contribution.
December 21, 2006 at 11:59 PM in reply to: In case you missed it, the BloodyNews Steven Piziks interview! #16099granville1
ParticipantJustin, thanks for the clarification and data – you cleared it up for me.
December 20, 2006 at 11:59 PM in reply to: In case you missed it, the BloodyNews Steven Piziks interview! #16095granville1
ParticipantThanks, guys for your comments. I must be way out of the loop – I was unaware that there was a novelization of Dominion. Is this a standard paperback that was widely distributed…? I never saw it at Borders…
granville1
ParticipantAnother creative idea… sounds good.
granville1
ParticipantThanks for the insightful comments… yeah, the Casablanca quote is crucial and unfortunately is “missing”…
granville1
ParticipantGhetto
I applaud your re-scoring, but if I may be so bold, I think the audience may experience it as intrusive. Since Regan has not done any of the singing in the movie that she did in the novel, folks might wonder “who” is singing and what it signifies. I recognized it as the “Tantum Ergo” from the Benediction service in the Catholic Church on Fridays during Lent. As such, for me and other ancient Catholics and ex-Catholics, it may seem not so much creepy as nostalgic. (It may have been creepy if it had been used in the film and Regan was singing it. Like Douriff’s singing in Legion. But if it had been used by the possessed Regan, it probably would not be suitable for the finale, since that might imply that she’s still possessed).
But I think your use of it points in the right direction, because it frames the film between two prayers, namely, the Moslem chant and the Tantum Ergo.
Granted, TVYNS does frame the film between two prayers, but the re-use of the Moslem chant at the end does not indicate any change in direction for the story and characters. I personally always experienced the Moslem chant at the beginning as part of the eeriness and alien-ness of the subject matter, which sets the mood for the entire film (Moslem audiences would probably experience this differently, of course). So repeating the Moslem chant – for me – does nothing but bring back the terrifying mood of the film’s opening – which is clearly not Friedkin’s intention.
If the finale’s Moslem chant could be “mixed” with some of the other used or unused scores – music that would perhaps contain an unobtrusive major chord that would modify the “tone” of the chant – then the ending Moslem chant might be “tilted” toward a positive interpretation.
I hope you don’t think I’m being overly critical – thanks for doing the new scoring and sharing it. I think TVYNS’s ending created musical and context problems anyway.
I liked Kinderman and Dyer getting together, and the continuance of Karras’ joke “I’ve seen it” – but I wish Kinderman’s dialogue about who’s starring in the play had been different. Anyway, thanks for your contributions.
December 19, 2006 at 11:59 PM in reply to: In case you missed it, the BloodyNews Steven Piziks interview! #16086granville1
ParticipantAny word if Beginning paperback will be worth anything down the road as a collector’s item? I got mine at Borders, which I believe only took on three copies…
granville1
ParticipantChanges:
THE ORIGINAL: Delete Karl’s “She is going to be well?” from the staircase “crucifix interrogation” scene – it doesn’t make much sense unless you’ve read the book, and it’s misplaced. Ditto Karl’s “It wants no straps” – most folks don’t put this line together with the soon-to-follow “You might loosen these straps, then”. The audience doesn’t know what on earth he’s talking about unless they catch on when Karras is asked to loosen the straps, but even then, the first line is obtrusive… If audio-technically possible, re-voice Karras’ dialogue in the tavern from, “I think I’ve lost my faith” to “I think I’m losing my faith”. This would permit an ember of faith to remain in Karras, and explain why he still says Mass, wears clerical garb, and has not dropped out of Church and priesthood altogether.
TVYNS: Delete Pazuzu on the bedroom wall when Chris finds the open window – it looks like a slide projection… The “lights-out” kitchen doesn’t need the Howdy faces… Delete the bloody-mouthed spider walk and replace it with the long-tongued spider walk – the latter is spookier, and very close to the scene in Blatty’s novel… If audio-technically possible, delete Sydow’s wheezy nasal exhaling on the “stairs conversation” scene – for me, it distracts from his dialogue… Delete the Moslem prayer chant from the final scene: leave it without music or put another track in.
granville1
ParticipantBad Locust,
Thanks for your comments. Lance Henriksen is so damned good I wish the movie itself had been better. I also agree that Sam Neill did a fantastic job with the adult Damien – it was quite a while before I could accept him in non-evil-type roles after I saw his Damien.
I also fantasize that the late great Jerry Goldsmith could have expanded the “Observatory/New Christmas Star” and “Second Coming” themes into an extended religious piece. In the late 60s, he had done something called “Christus Apollo”, underscoring Ray Bradbury’s poem of the same title. It would have been interesting to experience a Goldsmithian “spiritual” symphony since he did so well with such themes in
Poltergeist and The Omen…granville1
ParticipantWonderful job, deep feeling…
granville1
ParticipantI never found any of the Omen films to be frightening. They rely too much on standard, boring horror cliches – lightning flashes, mutilation, stupid, cartoon-like accidents, animal attacks, decapitation, unecessarily ugly/”spooky” characters, clueless parents/witnesses, sick, fucked-up clerics, etc. (I nearly fell out of my chair LOL when the priest tries to tell Peck that Damien was born of a wild dog. Talk about a ludicrous and un-scary premise.)
One of Omen’s greatest flaws is that – unlike The Exorcist – it panders to the worst gullibilities of popular and fundamentalist religion. Hence, since the Christmas Star was (fundamentalism says) a real/literal/factual star, so the Second Coming must be heralded by another “real” celestial phenomenon (this time, an alignment). Just as Jesus was “really” born of a “real virgin”, so too Damien’s birth must have a literal, physical parallel (conception by and birth from a jackal)to the literalist understanding of Jesus’ birth. Not to mention the film’s primary conceit that the Book of Revelation and the “666” myth describe both a real, factual, literal AntiChrist and our modern times.
But the trilogy’s most monumental gaffe is that human action is crucial to the AntiChrist’s defeat. This is a completely unscriptural view: even if one fundamentalistically takes the Book of Revelation literally, that book nowhere claims that humans are to have an active part in the “Final Conflict”. Rather, God, Jesus, and the angels are the sole pro-human “comabatants”. Not even the most vicious diatribes of the Jewish Dead Sea Scrolls envision a human participation in God’s vengeful “end time” purges. The Christian Testament holds a similar view.
A corollary to the Omen’s notion of a human intervention in the “end times” is the idea that the plan of an “almighty” God can be defeated if humans cannot stab the AntiChrist with the Daggers of Meggido. If that notion is taken seriously, it means that God is not almighty and is powerless to defeat the AntiChrist except through the good or the bad luck of the human wielders of the Daggers. And the wielders don’t need to be godly or even religiously literate. They just need to 1) have the daggers and 2) successfully strike their target.
Another unpleasant, arbitrary feature of The Omen is the introduction of unspooky “spooky” characters, e.g., goon clerics – sick, weird and/or nasty priests, e.g., the creepy priest with the eye disease who warns Peck of Damien’s dog-birth, or the shockingly wasted performance of Leo McKern as Bugenhagen in Omen II. Compare these nasty characters to the priests of The Exorcist, who though they are human beings struggling with human problems, are nonetheless plain-speaking, rational, reasonably healthy, compassionate, desirous to serve, genuinely concerned with Regan and with Karras… and they don’t carry around dark secrets wrapped up in physical and mental grotesquerie. The Omen, on the other hand, introduces creep-priests because it doesn’t have enough genuine scares to deliver – so it pads the job by planting the script thick with nasty stock characters.
But none of this “stuff and nonsense” is present in The Exorcist. Satan, through the medium of a powerful demon, is already present on earth. No fundamentalistic echoing of scripture is required to establish Satan’s presence and power. No “virgin birth from the split womb of a wild dog” is necessary. The Exorcist’s demon is not constrained by mythical daggers, the efforts of inept/crazy clerics… nor is he particularly susceptible to Christian ritual exorcism.
The Exorcist delivers real horror – with very little borrowing from horror genre cliches. And when it does borrow from cliches (e.g., the sound of wind-blown tree branches as Chris ascends alone to the attic holding a candle) – it delivers sparingly and effectively.
And it delivers stark demonology without the claptrap of popular religion, fundamentalism and outright mythical invention (the Daggers; “666” on Damien’s scalp; comic opera priest-assassins).Except for Jerry Goldsmith’s three outstanding musical scores, the Omen trilogy is just so much junk. The Omen and its sequels are not in The Exorcist’s league by any stretch of imagination, normal or febrile. Not by a long shot. Not by light years.
granville1
ParticipantI tend to agree, Captain. Merrin is the “bookends” of both movie and book. Even the doubting Karras is led to think that maybe Merrin can do something where Karras failed…
granville1
ParticipantThanks Jenny and Hatter for your comments!
granville1
ParticipantOops, per my original post: Ilya Kuriakin in Man from Uncle was played by David McCallum (sp?), not “McCullough” – sorry about that.
granville1
ParticipantHey, good catch!
-
AuthorPosts
CaptainHowdy.com The #1 Exorcist Fansite Since 1999