granville1

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 691 through 705 (of 874 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • granville1
    Participant

    Taking WPB’s side for a moment, it was a shame that all too many viewers thought that the demon won. This is even after showing them that Karras 1) invited the demon to “come into me”; 2) the demon did just that (viz. Karras’s demon makeup); 3) Karras takes the demon out the window with him; and 4) Karras is back to his old self when he dies – he is conscious and makes a last confession to Dyer via hand clasping.

    Maybe it would have been helped by a line of dialogue from the novel, where Karras says, “I won’t let you hurt them [her] – you’re coming with me!” Then audiences would almost _have_ to understand that Karras tempts, grapples with, and finally defeats the demon.

    If that understanding had been made explicit and unavoidable, then there would have been no need to consider those tack-on endings of the posthumous Karras walking up the steps or jogging, etc.

    granville1
    Participant

    Except that it foiled the author’s intent, namely Blatty’s insistence that audiences definitely understand that Karras, not the demon, won. This bothered WPB at the time of the film’s release, and for years afterward.

    Nor do I think that adding the line “I won’t let you hurt them [her]” or “You’re coming with me!” supplies a “sudden perfect picture” – for the simple reason that these lines are present in the novel, and represent WPB’s authorial intention.

    Ambivalence vis a vis the exorcism’s final outcome is valid as part of the first part of telling the story – the suspense builds to climax and denoument.

    But at the climax and denoument, to maintain ambivalence is a cheat to both the book reader and the film viewer. Friedkin championed the ambivalence-to-the-end view. Blatty championed the “Karras definitely won, the demon definitely lost” view. As the creator and sole proprietor of his own material, Blatty’s view should enjoy the prime position.

    in reply to: Why is Pazuzu in Karras’ dream? #17044
    granville1
    Participant

    Is Pazuzu in Karras’ dream? I recall the Howdy face, not Pazuzu.

    in reply to: More Music Excerpts… #17010
    granville1
    Participant

    I can only agree with your expertise and assessments… Yeah, it’s a pity that the sound is overlooked, even by those who should be most interested in it…

    in reply to: More Music Excerpts… #17005
    granville1
    Participant

    Great comments. I love what you said about all the subtle sounds on the Exorcist soundtrack – as you say, a brilliant ploy that puts the film under your skin…

    in reply to: More Music Excerpts… #17001
    granville1
    Participant

    I was chiefly impressed that the film used pre-existing music rather than hiring a specific composer (Lalo Schifrin’s score was rejected and some of it re-used, if memory serves, in The Amityville Horror).

    This tended to give the film a timeless tone – much as did Kubrick’s use of classical music for 2001. Although Jerry Goldsmith, Alex North, Bernard Herrman and others could have done a competant job with The Exorcist, I believe that ultimately the film gained from the more abstracted music finally chosen than it would have from a standard soundtrack composition.

    The interesting thing to me is that the editing-in of pre-existing music was done so well that none of it seems obtrusive. The music is widely variegated – yet, there remains a wholeness of tone, almost as if the music pre-selected itself.

    Thanks for the Penderecki information. I’ve always been a film music fan and anything relating to it – including the use of outside sources – is usually quite interesting to me!

    in reply to: Exorcisms and Dr. Phil #16998
    granville1
    Participant

    It’s always struck me that Bob Larson and other of his fundamentalist brethren wouldn’t know a real possession if it swam up and bit them in the brain. They don’t seem to be operating from the nuanced, responsible position laid out in the Roman Ritual. For them, just about anything negative – from drinking to cursing to bad habits – can be ascribed to “Satan”. If Larson wants to prove a case for possession, he’d better provide serious, scientifically verified paranormal events (the kind of things Karras was trying to find in the MacNeal case).

    in reply to: New scans! #16974
    granville1
    Participant

    Yeah, it was spooflike tho’ probably intending the opposite. The first copy of Legion I bought had a “cut-away” cover but the underlying page illustration was of a crazy-looking priest in a confessional (if memory serves) – but without the other characters shown in your selection. I lost my first copy – now I have the movie tie-in edition with a photo from the movie (I think it’s the Hitchcock Steps and Kinderman at the top of the stairs).

    in reply to: New scans! #16970
    granville1
    Participant

    Thanks for more great finds, Blizzi. It’s been years since I read the MAD spoof… the illustrator had a colossal talent for sketching our favorite Exorcist characters – and other celebrities.

    in reply to: question about a scene in the exorcist had me wondering #16966
    granville1
    Participant

    Thanks, Cap’n… appreciate your overlooking my goof – I still don’t know how I did it..

    in reply to: question about a scene in the exorcist had me wondering #16960
    granville1
    Participant

    Okay – fixed it. For anybody who cares, it’s back in a modified form in the Tarantino thread.

    in reply to: question about a scene in the exorcist had me wondering #16958
    granville1
    Participant

    What the heck happened? I thought I was replying in another thread vis a vis Tarantino and The Beginning. Sorry – must have gotten off track somehow.

    in reply to: question about a scene in the exorcist had me wondering #16957
    granville1
    Participant

    The Beginning was total trash whereas Tarantino does have some artistic flair. However, with MIKE, I also feel the need to shower after watching Tarantino.

    I got that same “dirty” feeling with The Beginning. It’s as if both filmmakers sprayed their glandular secretions all over the screen, and if audiences got splattered… so m

    So I would agree with Captain Howdy that The Beginning was trash, but also with MIKE that both The Beginning and Tarantino’s films convey an almost palpable sense of filth and nastiness.

    in reply to: question about a scene in the exorcist had me wondering #16939
    granville1
    Participant

    Good interpretation, Jay – at least that’s how this scene always affected me…

    granville1
    Participant

    Thanks for the kind words, pazrags, but I hadn’t thought of this question before… but my .02 cents:

    Performing the exorcism in a church would probably have required the bishop’s permission and I doubt there was time to procure that. The film gives the impression that Morning rushed over to the psycho ward cell as soon as he could, with or without a bishop’s permision.

    Also, a church, as a public place, would have had to been locked up, which would have brought attention to the exorcism – something to be avoided at all costs.

    Another factor is the time frame – if the exorcism turned out to last days or months, the impracticality of a church exorcism would become even more exacerbated.

    Re: what might happen in the church: if we extrapolate from what happened in Patient X’s cell in the psycho ward, the least we could expect in the church exorcism is a series of visionary encounters with some violent telekinesis.

    In the psycho ward exorcism there were no real snakes, no real lightning, no real cracks opening up in the floor, etc – those were subjective visions used by the demon to induce terror in Morning and Kinderman.

    There was a heat blast that seared Morning’s robes and his copy of the Roman Ritual, and there was a telekinetic force that nailed both Morning and Kinderman to the ceiling/wall (plus the force that ripped open Morning’s flesh).

    (There is also Miss Clelia’s ceiling walk, but that does not count as part of the exorcistic scene – note also, interestingly, that the Gemini, for all his powers, remains chained to his cot througout the exorcism. There is also the bleeding crucifix and the gust of “Pazuzu wind” in Morning’s room – but again, this was not involved in the exorcistic scene.)

    Put simply, there is in the film very little external paranormal violence, at least relative to the luridness of the visionary material. I don’t see why a church exorcism should be expected to necessarily exhibit anything very different. The special concern in a church exorcism, as mentioned, would be over the victim’s privacy and keeping the procedure from public scrutiny.

    Not to mention that by confining the exorcism to another “icy little room in Washington, D.C.”, Blatty continued the original Exorcist scenario of showing a huge evil confined to a small space.

Viewing 15 posts - 691 through 705 (of 874 total)