Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
granville1
ParticipantKeep ’em coming! You are an endless source of great horror stuff and you help to keep this group informed and entertained.
granville1
ParticipantOf course we’re interested! Thanks for sharing your blog, Blizzi. And I was impressed that you included a Lovecraft-archive site – he’s always been one of my very favorite horror writers.
May 2, 2007 at 11:59 PM in reply to: “As a community, we will bring this footage from the vaults to our respective DVD players.” #17070granville1
ParticipantMany congratulations, Captain! That’s wonderful news.
May 2, 2007 at 11:59 PM in reply to: “As a community, we will bring this footage from the vaults to our respective DVD players.” #17071granville1
ParticipantMany congratulations, Captain! That’s wonderful news.
May 2, 2007 at 11:59 PM in reply to: “As a community, we will bring this footage from the vaults to our respective DVD players.” #17072granville1
ParticipantLet me extend congrats a second time… my first posting seems to have disappeared!
May 2, 2007 at 11:59 PM in reply to: “As a community, we will bring this footage from the vaults to our respective DVD players.” #17073granville1
Participant(Sorry for taking up the bandwidth… now the first post has reappeared, along with two others that were meant to remedy that… I don’t know what’s going on here…)
granville1
ParticipantGreat finds, Justin – thanks for sharing.
granville1
Participantgranville1
ParticipantMaybe by the time The Exorcist was shot, Sal Mineo’s youthful looks had slid into middle-aged male bloat? Also his career had waned since the 1950s. That’s all I can suggest.
granville1
Participant“Evil against evil” I think was the museum curator’s comment – presumably as a Moslem – that the ancients fought evil (sickness, etc.) with evil, i.e., demonic help as represented in the Pazuzu amulet. Also, and this is a stretch, I wonder if Friedkin was hinting that the Jesuits are less than holy. He managed to film Merrin and Karras in rather spooky light and camera angles. Maybe he was winking at the audience – it takes evil Jesuits to fight evil demons. As I said, it’s a stretch.
May 1, 2007 at 11:59 PM in reply to: “As a community, we will bring this footage from the vaults to our respective DVD players.” #17066granville1
ParticipantHey, Cap’n… congratutlations!!!
granville1
ParticipantYeah, part of Blatty’s art is to allow a modicum of multiple choice without forcing a conclusion on the reader. The book would have suffered if the author’s meaning had been chiseled in stone…
granville1
ParticipantThat’s an original idea, MIKE, that a “trial” possession was going on. Works well for the movie. Of course, the book has Karras dreaming without Howdy or Pazuzu appearing… in fact, the demon is startled that Karras shows up, saying words to the effect, “You! They sent you?!” Karras and his faith crisis are known to the demon, but the demon was expecting to battle Merrin, not Karras…
granville1
ParticipantDifferent strokes for different folks, I guess… for me, the ambiguity in the novel works as a driving force of suspense, conflict, and dread – in the first three-quarters of the story. However, Blatty himself does all he can – again, in the novel, not in the Friedkin-influenced film – to resolve this issue at the _climax_ of the story.
Since he’s on record that he doesn’t want people to think the demon won, I think we can only interpret Karras’s last words – “No, I won’t let you hurt them – you’re coming with me!” – plus the glint of triumph Dyer sees in his eyes as he’s dying – as _vindicating_ the supernatural, genuine-possession view.
Otherwise, Karras’s self-sacrifice was for nothing – and remember, this is the opposite of Blatty’s intention – basically, Karras would have not committed “demonicide”, but suicide – worse, suicide based on a delusional belief in Regan’s possession.
Also, if the possession was not genuine and supernatural, there is no _unforced_ explanation as to why Regan’s possession ended with Karras’s inviting the demon to “come into me” and leaping out the window putatively carrying the demon with him.
Succinctly, the loss of the genuinely supernatural explanation:
1) vitiates Blatty’s authorial intention and so should be avoided, unless one is claiming that Blatty’s writing is so inept that it can’t carry thru his stated essential message;
2) vitiates Karras’s sacrifice, turning it into a sad, sick, unnecessary and meaningless suicide;
3) fails to explain Regan’s sudden recovery, immediate upon the seemingly genuine self-sacrifice by Karras;
4) fails to explain Chris’s summation of Karras: “I’ve never seen such faith”; fails to explain Kinderman’s nagging doubt that something strange still remains about the case, beyond mere mental illness and the rational conclusions of police forensics.
Therefore I believe, based on Blatty’s own statements and evidence internal to the novel’s structure, that the “genuine possession”/supernaturalist view is the correct one.
granville1
ParticipantI can only suggest premonition. Supposedly the unconscious is open to subtle influences, and we are “in” the unconscious when we are dreaming. So Karras may have been having a premonitory vision of the evil he will face in the near future.
(Also, come to think of it, Pazuzu does appear during the exorcism in the shared vision of Karras, Merrin, and Regan – when the Iraq Pazuzu statue momentarily appears in the bedroom after Karras and Merrin have been knocked to the floor.)
I suppose that if Captain Howdy is only a local manifestation of Pazuzu – one tailored to spiritually seduce a 12-year-old who is lonely for her Dad – then it doesn’t matter much whether it’s Pazuzu or Howdy who appears in Karras’s dream. So I’d grant your point that in a sense it _is_ Pazuzu who appears in Karras’s dream – albeit in his “Howdy” guise. Perhaps Karras’s unconscious is somehow connecting to Regan’s mind and Pazuzu/Howdy is being channeled to Karras via the unconscious…? I wouldn’t want to take it too literally though – maybe it’s meant as a literary device of shading – to be merely suggestive rather than concrete…
-
AuthorPosts
CaptainHowdy.com The #1 Exorcist Fansite Since 1999