granville1

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 706 through 720 (of 874 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Dr. Amfortas’ illness? #16934
    granville1
    Participant

    Good pun-catches! I don’t recall what he wrote when Temple was knocking… Guess I’ll need to re-read it again…

    in reply to: when the demon enters karras why then?… #16928
    granville1
    Participant

    Well, Blizzi, thank you.

    I really do think that, in the original story and film, a plot element of Karras’ re-possession by Gemini/Pazuzu, would certainly weaken the case for the redemption of “our beloved Damien Karras”.

    Of course, Blatty consented to weaken the case when he agreed that Karras would personally re-appear as in the clutches of Gemini-Pazuzu. Guess we can blame Morgan Creek for that, at least in part.

    Actually, re: a second application of the demonic yellow eyes to indicate that Karras, after successfully exorcising Regan, was re-possessed:

    It strikes me that KARRAS WAS NOT ACTUALLY RE-POSESSED AT ALL!

    He really exorcised Regan. He really “took the demon out the window” with him. He really saw a vision of God’s glory. Then, just before going on to his reward, he was abducted by Gemini-Pazuzu.

    However, abduction does not equal possession. Karras was in the power of the demons, but his mind was clear (“Save your servant”) and his soul, though tormented was his own – and still good.

    Granted, having this evil befall him after his heroic actions in saving Regan is a really nasty brutalization of a truly likeable and saintly character.

    But it’s not as bad as actual possession. Karras, in the Legion to be demonically tortured, certainly, but as himself, unmarred by re-possession.

    Damien Karras, we may comfort ourselves, was not re-possessed. He was demonically kidnapped, with soul and mind inviolate and intact!

    in reply to: karras on the cross in Exorcist III Legion #16929
    granville1
    Participant

    Thanks, you guys. I agree with Captain that MC wanted exorcistic effects, i.e., Catholic sacramentals.

    I also think that Blatty was hinting at Karras’s identification with the divine Victim (the crucified Christ), as well as human victims (the “crucified” human race). Recall his inability to resist the call of others, from the alcoholic (“couldja help an old altar boy”) to whom he gives his last pocket money (unlike the cinematic Karras, who walks away), to the troubled seminarian, to Chris MacNeil, etc.

    The Christian message is to take up your cross and follow Jesus, and frequently in the Roman Empire this meant literally taking up a literal cross (or being executed in some other way). Hence Karras on the cross is symbolic both of the crucified Christ, of Christian service in “taking up your cross daily”, and of compassion toward suffering, “crucified” people in general. Certainly he is being obviously identified with the black boy who had been crucified on rowing oars, and with the headless Christ statue – complete with ingot in its eyes – that appears on the cross just prior to the actual crucified Karras’s appearance.

    Maybe I’m reading too much into it, this is just my .02 cents.

    in reply to: Dr. Amfortas’ illness? #16931
    granville1
    Participant

    Not epilepsy, but likely a brain “legion” (sorry). Recall that Amfortas duplicates the symptoms of his own patients (the hand convulsion). His “twin” informs him that yes, he had a part in the murders. The haunting question is, can Amfortas, like Karras before him, be redeemed?

    Also the name “Amfortas” is taken from the Grail myth. Amfortas was the Fisher King who chronically/eternally suffered from a debilitating wound. In fact, his wound (said to be in the thigh and symbolic of physical and spiritual impotence) is called “The Amfortas Wound”. Hence Blatty’s Dr. Amfortas also suffers from a chronic psychological (the problem of pain) wound – and a neurological (his lesion and the altered state it causes) wound.

    So – yes, I’d say that Amfortas is the guilty party vis a vis the murdered priest in the confessional. He had access to the surgical shears and the succinocholine. But I don’t know if he can be termed a true catatonic – the brain lesion is probably classified as a different type of illness in neuropsychology.

    in reply to: when the demon enters karras why then?… #16925
    granville1
    Participant

    Of course, Legion was a tack-on. In the Legion novel, Karras only appears as his re-animated body. Karras is not present as a person. In fact the Gemnini himself says that Karras has gone on to his reward.

    It is only in the Legion _film_ that Karras himself re-appears as a victim of (re-)possession, having been captured by demons in an act of demonic revenge.

    Blatty’s book and Friedkin’s novel are explicit that Karras was redeemed and had a renewal of faith. The novel says his eyes had a glint of peace and triumph. Blatty is on record that the demon did not win.

    The notion of Karras as having been re-captured by a demon or demons is solely the conceit of the Legion _film_. Blatty’s Legion novel wisely preserves Karras’s salvation.

    Therefore, I believe it would be a mistake to consider tampering with the SFX (the yellow demonic eyes) at the end of The Exorcist to indicate that – after offering himself for possession, being possessed, and then throwing off the demon’s power – Karras had been possessed again.

    That would only serve to invalidate his “hand-grasping confession” to Dyer, to confuse the question of his salvation, and to vitiate Blatty’s entire intention.

    in reply to: Fixing the Finale #16913
    granville1
    Participant

    If the topic is fixing the finale, lots of us are on record that it cannot be fixed because the entire film is toxic all the way thru. Short of re-shooting the whole thing, what can be done?

    in reply to: Rare Jason Miller pics #16897
    granville1
    Participant

    Yeah – thanks for sharing all the cool pix.

    in reply to: Fixing the Finale #16896
    granville1
    Participant

    Yeah, I thought the normally excellent Morricone flopped with this musical score (maybe acting out his rebellion against the obnoxious material?). I thought Regan’s Theme was sweet and melancholy, but for that very reason it was obtrusive amid the junkiness of its surroundings…

    in reply to: Fixing the Finale #16891
    granville1
    Participant

    Amidst the “scary” locust swarm, Lamont has a vision of Merrin (like TVYNS has Karras see a vision of his mother) just before sacrificing his life for Blair, Fletcher, Sharon, and the world. This rubs out the obnoxious Lamont character and hints that he “went to heaven”. A truly stupid scenario, but quite in keeping with this truly aberrated film. OTOH, if we’re trying to “fix” the finale based only on juggling/cutting existing footage – forget it. A poison turkey is poisoned in all its parts.

    in reply to: Fixing the Finale #16894
    granville1
    Participant

    Yeah, the only appropriate ending would be to show Boorman taking an endless series of pratfalls.

    granville1
    Participant

    Your attention to detail is very impressive!

    granville1
    Participant

    … good catch. And doesn’t Karras die around Mother’s Day.. I think the demon says something about it being Mother’s Day in order to taunt Karras about his relationship with his mother…

    in reply to: Real Chris and Regan of the novel :D #16838
    granville1
    Participant

    I’m constantly amazed at just how _much_ WPB lifted from real people in drawing his Exorcist characters, from Shirley and Sachi to the film director who became Burke Dennings..

    in reply to: Real Chris and Regan of the novel :D #16805
    granville1
    Participant

    lunoso, thanks for the Thompson photo… he kind of looks like how I always imagined Dennings looked like.

    in reply to: question about the church in exorcist III #16822
    granville1
    Participant

    Thanks, Blizzi… I might modify it, however, based on input from Justin and probably some others, that the scene may not be the actual exorcism night, but maybe the point at which “Patient X” was finally “captured” wandering the C&O Canal. But I would continue to view these scenes as a dreamlike, symbolic, metaphorical mix of Karras’ own confused memories and experiences.

Viewing 15 posts - 706 through 720 (of 874 total)