granville1

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 661 through 675 (of 874 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • granville1
    Participant

    Nice points. As you say, poltergeist theory is frequently based on adolescent trauma, which could have been involved in this case. Certainly, this “etiology” is invoked in other cases, such as the Bell Witch incident.

    in reply to: Legion: Merrin, Jung, Teilhard, Gnosticism #17207
    granville1
    Participant

    Thanks, Blizzi – glad you enjoyed it.

    granville1
    Participant

    I really don’t understand the originating question, “why did he jump anyway?”…

    Karras jumped because (whether rightly or mistakenly) he thought that the way to get the demon out of the MacNeil house for good was to take it out the window with him: ” I won’t let you hurt them – you’re coming with me!” is not the cry of a man who has any illusions about the consequences of jumping out the window with the demon inside of him. He will smash the shutters and jump – and if he is killed in the process, so be it: Regan and family will be safe.

    This is why I find Blatty saying that Karras hopes there will be “a net out there” irrational and incoherent.

    First, Karras doesn’t really have time to think ahead that far.

    Second, had he been thinking about the jump, he’d be a moron to think that he could possibly escape without horrendous if not fatal injuries.

    Third, if Karras was really the highly logical person the novel presents him as being, he would not be likely to fantasize about a “net” – whether physical or metaphorical – to buffer his fall.

    Fourth, a “net-hoping” Karras contradicts the “man for others” type of compassion he has manifested throughout the book: throughout, he gives himself utterly to others, no matter how it hurts, regardless of the consequences. To have Karras, at the very end of his life, and as his very last act, suddenly turn cold, calculating, and avoiding toward his own compassionate impulses, vitiates the Karras that Blatty has so skillfully etched – as well as introducing an obtrusively gratuitous venality to this saintly character.

    If Blatty really said that Karras was hoping for a net, I can only think that Blatty was having an incautious moment, and made a verbal faux pas.

    granville1
    Participant

    That’s basically how I remember it, too. The book even briefly theorizes that it was the deceased aunt’s spirit that was behind the manifestations. Additionaly, it theorizes that the aunt, while introducing the kid to occult stuff, may also have been molesting him. If memory serves, the book doesn’t follow up much on these two ideas.

    in reply to: Haha… Not helping… #17188
    granville1
    Participant

    Good find… especially nice to see stills from that movie he made about the priest helping the poor (can’t recall the title).

    in reply to: McNeil residence interiors #17183
    granville1
    Participant

    Not I.. sounds interesting, though.

    in reply to: Haha… Not helping… #17170
    granville1
    Participant

    Yeah, they sound a bit snippy… it’s nice you tried, though.

    in reply to: Fellow monsters… #17164
    granville1
    Participant

    Hope you can stay on…

    in reply to: Mental illness/possession #17160
    granville1
    Participant

    I would like to see a collage of views of Blatty’s work. Included might be an examination of his “Angel” theory (which he got from a friend) in Legion. In some ways it resembles a kind of Gnostic creation myth and it resonates with some of the Merrin stuff from the first novel…

    in reply to: Site Downtime #17141
    granville1
    Participant

    Glad it’s back to normal – I need my Howdy fix!

    in reply to: boy this sucks… #17140
    granville1
    Participant

    Yeah, I couldn’t access it for about 3 days… Firefox said the server was not available.

    in reply to: Why is Pazuzu in Karras’ dream? #17121
    granville1
    Participant

    Good point.

    in reply to: Why is Pazuzu in Karras’ dream? #17117
    granville1
    Participant

    I think the novel supports Howdy’s attractiveness – initially, that is. After all, he is a surrogate Dad for Regan. He wins her trust before he torments her. Regan is shocked when the attractive, friendly Howdy changes into her nemesis. If he had first appeared to her as ugly and evil, his initial “seduction” (or invasion, or infestation) would have failed. Blatty shows the demon as insidiously insinuating himself into Regan’s consciousness, the first stage of which is via his ouija board communications. Regan perceived these as interesting and friendly.

    The movie could be seen to support Howdy’s demonic hideousness, but this is based on a huge “IF”: namely, is the white-faced figure really Howdy? Or is it just a manifestation of Pazuzu’s living character (as opposed to his humanly-interpreted statue as seen in Iraq)?

    The film never tags Captain Howdy with any explicit visual identifiers. TVYNS does show Regan seeing the white-faced demon in the doctor’s office, but again, this is never explicitly identified with Howdy or any other specific character, demonic or otherwise. The audience is left to put Howdy together with the white-faced demon – or not.

    in reply to: Why is Pazuzu in Karras’ dream? #17119
    granville1
    Participant

    Yeah, that there is only one holds true for the original novel. But then Blatty modified that concept in Legion: the demon was controlling Venamun’s spirit, inserting him into Karras’s re-animated body. And there’s also the good twin “backstage” with whom the Gemini is in sporadic spiritual contact. Therefore, viewing Blatty’s demonology as a whole, it seems that he thinks that there can, after all, be more than one possessing entity within, or at least manipulating, a single victim.

    in reply to: New scans! #17099
    granville1
    Participant

    As always, Blizzi, thanks for the great article and photos…

Viewing 15 posts - 661 through 675 (of 874 total)