Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
granville1
ParticipantSince they persuaded Von Sydow to return in the role, they should have used more of him in this film. More Merrin, less Lamont. Probably the African scenes are the only ones approaching watchability, but even they suffer from Boorman’s disastrous direction and the abysmal screenplay.
Blatty’s novel and the first film established that the demon is a liar, and that the multiple entities housed in a possession victim may be the demon’s “cover”. As Merrin said, “There is only one.” To ferret out the demon’s true identity is a crucial point in exorcism.
But in the Boorman film, the demon conveniently hands Merrin his name: “I am Pazuzu!” before Merrin even realizes that the kid is possessed. Demons customarily don’t like to identify themselves, because, according to legend, this will give the exorcist power over them.
I found the climb up the cliff face utterly hysterical, Merrin’s voice cracking, the porter falling off the cliff, lugging the kid up with ropes, etc. And the exorcism, which in Blatty’s book took months and damn near killed Merrin, seems accomplished in about five minutes. Moreover, the ritual works. In Blatty’s novel and the first film, the ritual is ineffective, and the only thing that saves the possession victim is Karras’ self-sacrifice. It’s as if Boorman’s stated contempt for Blatty’s novel and Blatty’s and Friedkin’s film compelled him to get rid of Merrin and the exorcism ASAP.
So much more could have been done with a director who respected Blatty’s ideas.
granville1
ParticipantThanks Hatter and Justin for your input…It’s nice to hear your comments.
granville1
ParticipantGood luck, come back as often as you can.
granville1
ParticipantPazrags, thanks for the nice words, but sorry – I’m not a fiction writer. I can’t write believable dialogue, for one thing. Another thing is I would need to create a delicately-balanced suspense story – like Blatty did in the original novel – which keeps the reader wondering if it’s really Kinderman or if there are other viable suspects, or if this is another truly demonic “invasion” of Georgetown. I doubt I’m capable of pulling it off – I’ve never been to Georgetown and would surely make descriptive errors. Also I’d have to resolve Julie Kinderman’s disappearance – will she show up alive again? If she doesn’t, what will that do to the general tone of the story? Would we want Kinderman to survive if it turns out that he _did_ kill Julie and the other victims? Unlike Blatty I don’t know anything about police forensics and couldn’t really supply the necessary authentic feel. Then there is which source to follow – Blatty’s Legion novel, or the Legion film? Or an inconsistent mixing of both?
But since you asked I will send another, short, post with an idea of concluding the story: beware, it’s dark and probably a bit contrived and silly.
granville1
ParticipantFor Pazrags: conclusion to potential Legion sequel:
Eventually Kinderman, though evidence points to him as the killer, has neurological testing that shows that there is nothing in his brain/nervous system that would account for dissociative states or violent fugues. Either he is nuts but neuroscience cannot reveal medical reasons for it, or there are parties – human or otherwise – responsible for the new wave of homicide.
Kinderman finally begins to consult Father Paul Morning, who humbly and quietly shares his knowledge of demonic possession. These descriptions are harrowing and nearly drive Kinderman over the edge, especially as he knows that he is somehow the target of whoever is doing the murders. Morning describes the exorcism that turned his hair white overnight.
As Kinderman’s interviews with Morning continue over the weeks, he does a bit of research into Morning’s past, with a special emphasis on the hair-whitening exorcism. He finds the records on Morning rather spotty. Apparently Morning has traveled widely, never staying in one locale for very long. Not unusual for a missionary priest, yet it seems that in nearly every place Morning has been assigned, there has been demonic activity and exorcism. Eventually, Kinderman contacts several of the people Morning has exorcised in the past.
A disturbing picture emerges. Kinderman wonders why Morning is so horribly unlucky that he encounters demonic activity wherever he goes. Then it occurs to him that bad luck may have nothing to do with it. Could it be possible that Morning’s presence actually causes demons to flock to him? But why would they do this if he is such a successful exorcist? And why do the people Morning exorcized speak of him reluctantly and with visible discomfort and fear?
Finally, one of Morning’s exorcised people show up in Kinderman’s squad room. This person shows Kinderman horrible scarring dating from the exorcism. Kinderman asks, “The demon did all that?” The person replies, “No, sir. Faddah Mornin’ did it.”
Kinderman goes to Morning with this new evidence. After listening to Kinderman’s story, Morning smiles at Kinderman, saying, “This time you are going to lose.” And there, in an icy little room in Washington, D.C., William Kinderman finds himself locked in this, the final struggle in the Exorcist narrative.
granville1
ParticipantMike, thanks for the very kind words. I’m delighted that you think the story fits in the Blatty “tone”.
granville1
ParticipantMerrin doesn’t have the heart attack. Karras doesn’t jump out the window. Regan MacNeil dies. A “downer” much worse than the one some people think happened, namely Karras either committing suicide or being forced out the window, “murdered” by the demon. Regan’s death would be a gaping black hole, leaving nothing but grief and terrible, terrible questions. A truly _horrific_ ending to a horror novel.
granville1
ParticipantYeah, that’s been done to death too…
granville1
ParticipantThanks, Hatter.
granville1
ParticipantThe University president is found dead, crucified in the chapel and with the mark of the Gemini carved into his flesh. The mother of the Police Club boy, who discovered that Regan spoke English in reverse, is found dead by a similar M.O. Ditto the University president’s secretary, who brought him the copy of his speech in the Legion film.
Kinderman, shocked and horrified, investigates. As the investigation proceeds, Kinderman is astonished to see all the clues pointing to … himself. Is he somehow committing these murders? Is he insane? Possessed? Is he dissociated (like Amfortas was in the novel)?
How long can he deflect the obvious conclusions – and their import? Of anyone in Georgetown, Kinderman is the single person who has the most information about The Gemini.
He is only beginning to absorb these factors when his detectives, Ryan and Stedman, are found on the canoe dock, heads turned completely around, facing backward.
And Kinderman recalls with a chill that whenever possible, The Gemini selected victims whose names began with the letter “K”. When Julie Kinderman, his daughter, mysteriously disappears in the middle of this crime wave, Kinderman must search intensively for her… and shun the realization that he may in some way be deeply connected to this, and the other, crimes.
Has Kinderman flipped? Has The Gemini, in another act of revenge, invaded Kinderman’s soul? Did The Gemini and/or the demon/Pazuzu leap from Karras into Kinderman when Kinderman shot Karras and “set him free”? Is someone in Kinderman’s own police force, possessed or not, reviving The Gemini’s crime spree?
Kinderman secretly and as discretely as possible seeks advice from the only source available: Father Paul Morning, who though mutilated and traumatized by his exorcism of Karras/The Gemini/the demon/Pazuzu, has survived, and whose wisdom and vast experience of possession may be the final hope for the haunted William F. Kinderman…
Pretty crappy, but it’s the best I could do…
granville1
ParticipantBlatty implies “then and there” that Karras would have killed everyone in the house he could have killed. He tells the demon, “No! I won’t let you hurt them!” The film shows this when it frames the now-unpossessed Regan framed in Karras’s would-be-strangling hands. Then Karras tells the demon, “NO!” and jumps thru the window. Blatty apparently thought the possessed Karras capable of killing everyone in the house. Blatty has already established Karras’s great physical strength and athleticism, and knows that the reader will look at Karras as doubly-dangerous in a possessed state.
I don’t think a “detailed theory” is supplied by Blatty beyond: “regular Karras = very strong”; “possessed Karras = very strong and very dangerous”.
granville1
ParticipantBlatty says that Regan had been exposed to religious ideas: 1) she had read material about possession; 2) she had desecrated the church and typed the blasphemous altar card (tho’ in a possessed or semi-possessed state); she knew that Willie and Karl were of Catholic background; she lived in predominantly Catholic Georgetown and thus presumably had seen her share of priests and nuns.
Therefore she had at least a background in understanding the meaning of the crucifix. She may well have sneaked it into her room as a protective talisman. Or, the demon, anticipating full control and the eventuality of self-rape with the crucifix, may have directed Regan to procure the cross for future use.
granville1
ParticipantActually, it is not a Bible – although it frequently references the Bible. It’s from the Roman Ritual which is found in the large red volume used in the films. Sorry but I don’t know where you could get a physical copy of it other than Googling Catholic bookstores and catalogues. Maybe if you just Googled “Roman Ritual” you could find an online text? It goes on for several pages. I think it may only exist as part of a larger body of prayers in the “red book”…
granville1
ParticipantIt does look inconsistent. However, the head of the language lab, a male, may have received the data from one of his workers/researchers who could have been a female, namely the black kid’s mother. Thus, the mother discovered that the tape was English in reverse, informed the language lab boss, and the boss then told Karras. It’s a stretch, but not impossible.
granville1
ParticipantI dunno – the visuals suggested that the demon cause his heart attack via reaching into his chest and ripping out his heart. Louise Fletcher, while linked into this scene, also suffers a “heart attack”.
The novel was pretty clear that Merrin’s heart gave out thru stress, not thru the demon’s action. In fact, the demon is angry that Merrin dies before the demon can kill him or morally defeat him. EX2/Heretic completely contradicts Blatty’s own scenario – just another instance of how much Boorman despised Blatty’s novel/Friedkin’s film.
-
AuthorPosts
CaptainHowdy.com The #1 Exorcist Fansite Since 1999