granville1

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 616 through 630 (of 874 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: The names Goneril & Regan – King Lear #17699
    granville1
    Participant

    Confession of dumbness: I didn’t know the literary reference of “Goneril”, I just thought it was some kind of old, odd, Anglo-Saxon or Germanic name. It’s taken all these years for you to enlighten me about the name.

    in reply to: The names Goneril & Regan – King Lear #17704
    granville1
    Participant

    Well, thanks for being so nice about my abysmal ignorance – and thanks for the great url.

    in reply to: The names Goneril & Regan – King Lear #17695
    granville1
    Participant

    Great post, Lunuso.

    in reply to: Poltergeists, ouija boards and such #17668
    granville1
    Participant

    Sounds like you’re taking a sane, cautious approach!

    in reply to: I made a slideshow/vidclip about the remaining cuts. #17613
    granville1
    Participant

    Thanks, guys, for the soundtrack info.

    in reply to: I made a slideshow/vidclip about the remaining cuts. #17606
    granville1
    Participant

    Ditto. Nice use of musical score too – do you mind if I ask what it is from?

    in reply to: Poltergeists, ouija boards and such #17607
    granville1
    Participant

    Haven’t used a ouija in years. I only have theories about it. I suppose, following C.G. Jung, that “the unconscious” can manipulate the participants’ finger pressure without the knowledge of the conscious ego-mind, and in extreme cases, perhaps a dissociated personality fragment could express itself thru the manipulations.

    If there are spirits floating around, I suppose theoretically, they, too, could “speak” in the same way. According to Legion and Konstantin Raudive, spirits are “in the air” and can “speak” via tape recordings, so – again, theoretically – they could also communicate thru a ouija board.

    As far as genuine demonic possession and genuine communication from spirit beings, I am agnostic, but open minded. In my admittedly limited reading, I’ve never come across a genuine case of possession, i.e., one that could not be explained by a combination of unconscious psychology and paranormal occurrences – i.e., I’ve never seen strong evidence for a truly nonmaterial, preternatural, discarnate, alien, non-human spiritual “invading” entity. Ditto ouija boards, seances, etc. To believe that external spirits are really at work, I’d need to see strong evidence of such.

    (Also, as an aside, Christianity generally condemns any such occult practices. Recall in The Exorcist novel that the Catholic “seeress” Mary Jo Perrin forcefully warns Chris against Regan’s use of the ouija board because it could “open a door” to evil…)

    in reply to: Possessed karras #17556
    granville1
    Participant

    Just now read your reply, Blizzi. Glad you liked my theory…

    in reply to: Resonances in the Friedkin film #17557
    granville1
    Participant

    Thanks, Blizzi… sorry to reply so late. Again, I’m not _certain_ it’s meant to show Merrin walking down a cross, but the way it’s framed sure suggests it to me…

    in reply to: Resonances in the Friedkin film #17560
    granville1
    Participant

    Thanks for the kind words, Captain. The film seems to yield more symbology the more one views it…

    granville1
    Participant

    I am glad you included Carpenter’s remake of The Thing among the imaginative/minimalist horror films. Seems all to many people condemn the film for its explicit gore and brutality, while at the same time missing its _extremely_ successful suspensefulness. I, for one, was on the edge of my chair due simply to Carpenter’s skillful direction. He could have gone the easy, lazy route of letting sfx alone bear the story’s weight, but instead he constructed a terrifyingly suspenseful narrative.

    Plus, I think the horror scenes were no more and no less than what was called for to tell the story, and in context were not “excessive”. (Also, I think the film does wonders with characterization, condensing authentically-toned personalities into the little material he had to work with, but that’s another issue…)

    in reply to: Odd Dream #17536
    granville1
    Participant

    That would make a neat “Exorcist dream sequence” for a future film…

    in reply to: Odd Dream #17547
    granville1
    Participant

    … if only…

    granville1
    Participant

    Me, too. In all of the possession cases I’ve read about, there has not been evidence “of the kind the Church would accept” as being manifestations of a truly discarnate superhuman invading personality. That leave us with an odd form of mental illness combined with paranormal activity – namely, poltergeist phenomena. Seems that Jung had some experiences with poltergeists for which he supplied a psychological explanation, e.g., a constellation of archetypes or a maladjusted adolescent, or some psychic crisis, etc…

    granville1
    Participant

    Nice idea, though I for one coudldn’t contribute much. My only exposure to poltergeist theory is:

    1) The poltergeist is an actual discarnate spirit causing kinetic environmental effects.

    2) The poltergeist is a discarnate soul of a deceased person.

    3) The poltergeist is a split-off portion of a living personality which manifests in psychokinetic effects.

    4) Ditto the above, with the personality being a stressed-out, traumatized person, usually an adolescent.

    5) The poltergeist is purely imaginary, the manifestations being due, at the least, to over-active imaginations, at the most, trickery on the part of the person around whom the manifestations center.

    That’s all I know about it, although others might have more to contribute.

Viewing 15 posts - 616 through 630 (of 874 total)