Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
July 15, 2007 at 11:59 PM in reply to: question about the real life exorcism of the possessed boy in maryland #18324
granville1
ParticipantThanks, Blizzi… I’m fortunate in that I have a few Jung books about the place…
granville1
ParticipantYes, nice to share like thoughts with like minds… and yes it would be nice to know what exactly is going on, providing the phenomenon will permit itself to be seized!
granville1
ParticipantBlizzi, “if we believe, how far could we go” should have been incorporated into Boorman’s Heretic – it would have intelligently complemented “the Good Regan/Good Locust/Teilhardian Omega Point” themes…
Ryan, yes, Amfortas was in a sense Legion’s “Karras figure” – full of suffering, looking for answers. Putting Amfortas in the movie would have made it gripping and poignant.
granville1
ParticipantMaybe so… a dialogue between him and Sunshine/Karras would have been a treat given Blatty’s talents…
granville1
ParticipantRyan, your idea about the mini-series was great and caused me much salivation.
granville1
ParticipantRyan, found one, looking for the other. This case is cited in The Exorcist itself as Karras is investigating.
Psychology and the Occult. C.G. Jung. Bolligen Series, 1977, Princeton University Press, pp. 55-56.
Jung discusses Myers’ 1885 work, “Automatic Writing”, citing the Clelia personality that emerged in automatic writing done by one “Mr. A”, a member of the Society for Psychical Research.
The emergent personality identifies itself as Clelia, a woman who “will come to life… in six years [in the future].”
Blatty’s cite of the case appears on pp. 325-327 of the Bantam paperback.
granville1
ParticipantHey, Ryan, found the other reference… the books were more accessible than I thought!
Jung, Memories, Dreams, Reflections. Vintage Books Edition, Random House, NY, pp. 124-125.
Same story Temple tells in Legion. Except in Legion he asks an old cobbler how shoes used to be sewn, whereas Jung found out by asking his clinic’s head nurse how long the woman had been making the gestures. The nurse told him that the prior head nurse had said that the old lady used to make shoes.
Jung next checked her delapidated records, which, surprisingly, indeed identified the gestures as cobbler’s motions.
At her funeral, Jung asked her brother how she lost her sanity, and the brother told Jung that she had been in love with a shoemaker who rejected her, and from that point, she became dysfunctional.
Jung: “The shoemaker movements indicated an identification with her sweetheart which lasted until her death… Henceforth I devoted all my attention to the meaningful connections in a psychosis.” (p.125)
July 12, 2007 at 11:59 PM in reply to: question about the real life exorcism of the possessed boy in maryland #18196granville1
ParticipantBlizzi, just adding Freud’s comment on the paranormal:
15 June 1911 Freud to Jung:
“In matters of occultism I have grown humble since the great lesson Ferenczi’s experiences gave me. I promist to believe anything that can be made to look reasonable. I shall not do so gladly, that, you know. But my hubris has been shattered.”
[Sandor Ferenczi, a psychoanalist, had also been experimenting with the paranormal.]
Jung. Psychology and the Occult. Bollingen Series, Princeton University Press, 1977, p. ix.
Freud had a life-long interest in the paranormal, regardless of his conclusions about the “cabinet poltergeist.”
granville1
ParticipantGlad you could use the stuff, Ryan.
granville1
ParticipantI’d agree about the recommended equipment. But if you do it, please exercise caution. If the voices have a non-natural source, it’s not certain who or what they are or where they come from. As Legion says, some of them are deceivers… and if that’s the case, some might be malevolent.
July 12, 2007 at 11:59 PM in reply to: Warner bros probably guilty of killing Anneliese Michel in real exorcism case of 1975/76 #18238granville1
ParticipantSo she may have watched the movie. The only real scandal is the dire superstition of her Roman Catholic friends, clergy, and of course, poor Anneliese herself. As the Church directive quoted in The Exorcist states, medical possibilities need to be exhausted before leaping to the supernatural. Folk-fundamentalism is a real killer.
granville1
ParticipantThanks, Blizzi.
granville1
ParticipantAstonishing Merrin-melding.
granville1
ParticipantGlad you’re being cautious.
I don’t know what to make of the voices – you bring up a deep issue as to why they wouldn’t skip the mike and go directly to the tape… but I suppose it could equally be asked why the woudn’t skip both mike and tape and manifest clearly as voices in the normal environment. Why are they “hiding” until we make the effort – and it’s quite an effort – to contact them?
I am torn, as usual, between a reductionist and a paranormal interpretation. I’ve heard some of these online and so many of the phrases and sentences can bear as many as three different interpretations. Is this (reductionism) simply because as with our vision, the brain tends to see or even construct patterns out of random signals? Or is it because “the spirits” can communicate more than one message in a single vocalization? I really don’t know.
The question – if we are interracting with an independent phenomenon – seems to center around the identity of the voices. If they are nonmaterial entities, that’s very interesting. On the other hand, if they are dissociated personality fragments from our own unconscious… that’s very interesting too, because in that case, we’d be talking to ourselves – only we’d be talking to the self-portions not normally known or available to the conscious ego.
Like I say, it’s fascinating, but I’m still in the speculative, rather than the certainty, phase.
granville1
ParticipantYou’re welcome – thanks for sharing the large pics.
-
AuthorPosts
CaptainHowdy.com The #1 Exorcist Fansite Since 1999