*gulp*
It's on par… how DARE I admit that, right? OK I take that back–
The themes The Exorcist explores are much deeper. The Exorcist stands as a more genre-changing horror film.
But The Shining is by Kubrick… and it's fucking brilliant. I'm happy for that film to beat The Exorcist to number 1 because I can see how it could be seen that way (especially today, as The Exorcist slowly gets dated with people *sniff*).
Had it been, like, TWILIGHT, we could kick up a fuss. But make no mistake, The Shining has very awesome things going on and is without-a-doubt a horror classic. One of my faves.